Pizza That Lowered My Blood Sugar
Jason Glover
Author
Jason Glover
Servings
4
Prep Time
24 hours
Cook Time
15 minutes
A delicious pepperoni pizza made with a blood sugar-friendly flour that didn’t spike my glucose—and even helped lower it. Perfect for diabetic-friendly eating.
I didn’t set out to reinvent pizza night—I just wanted a slice that wouldn’t send my blood sugar on a rollercoaster. Like a lot of people managing diabetes (or cooking for someone who is), I’d mostly accepted that “great pizza” and “stable glucose” didn’t really belong in the same sentence. But that changed the day I started experimenting with alternative flours.
After testing everything from almond to oat blends, I finally landed on a flour that completely surprised me. It handled like traditional dough, baked up with that perfect chew-meets-crisp texture, and—most importantly—didn’t cause the sharp spike I’d come to expect from regular white flour crusts. The real shock, though? The flavor. This wasn’t a “good for what it is” situation. This was actually incredible—the kind of crust that makes you pause mid-bite and go, “Wait… this is the healthy version?”
And here’s the part I still can’t quite get over: after eating it, my glucose numbers didn’t just stay steady—they actually went down. I checked twice because I was sure it had to be a fluke. Pizza that helps your numbers instead of hurting them? I was genuinely shocked.
Paired with a bold, spicy pepperoni and a simple tomato sauce, this dough creates a pizza that feels indulgent without the usual downside. It’s deeply satisfying, beautifully balanced, and proof that you don’t have to give up your favorite foods to take care of your body. In fact, you might end up liking this version even more.
Ingredients
Pizza Dough
-
2 cups Elevate Protein Flour
-
¼ tsp Rapid Rise instant yeast
-
1 ¼ tsp salt
-
½ tsp brown sugar
-
1 cup warm water at 105 degrees
Toppings
-
Pepperoni slices
1 cup shredded mozzarella -
½ cup Carbone Pizza Sauce
Tools
-
Stand mixer
-
Cutting board
-
Knife
Directions
- Combine all pizza dough ingredients in your stand mixer with a dough hook and start mixing on medium speed for 5-8 minutes until it forms a ball. If the ball hasn't formed you may need to add an additional 1 tbsp or so of water and continue mixing until the ball forms.
- Take the dough ball out of mixer and put in a bowl with a tbsp of olive oil at the bottom so the dough doesn't stick.
- Cover the bowl and let the dough rise for 24 hrs at room temperature.
- Pre- Heat your pizza oven to 650-700* or alternatively your oven or smoker to 500*+ with a pizza stone. Let heat up at least 30-45 minutes so the tiles/stones are hot. Otherwise the pizza will stick to your tile/stone and that's no good!
- Put a small amount of flour on a cutting board and start stretching the dough into a round circle.
- Add pizza sauce and desired toppings.
- Put the pizza in the pizza oven or oven/smoker.
- Cook for approximately 8 - 10 minutes or to desired doneness. If using a pizza oven make sure to turn your pizza every 30 seconds or so, so it doesn't burn.
- Pull it out, slice it up and serve!
Recipe Video
Recipe Note
Disclaimer
Everyone’s body responds to food differently, especially when it comes to diabetes. I personally manage my blood sugar through diet and am not on insulin, so my experience may not reflect yours. I can’t guarantee this flour will have the same effect for you, but I didn’t experience any significant spikes when eating it. If you’re diabetic and looking for alternatives, it may be worth trying and seeing how your body responds.